Stephen Browne Lawyers vs LHD Lawyers Perth: which should you pick?
Both firms sit at the top of Perth's injury and workers' compensation field, with near-identical scores and the same reputation for keeping clients informed through long, stressful claims. The real choice comes down to team size, review depth, and which named staff you'd rather have on your file, so here's how they stack up using our methodology.
The differences that matter
- Review volume and track record. Stephen Browne Lawyers has built up 537 reviews against LHD's 347, giving it a slightly deeper public track record at essentially the same 4.9 rating.
- Size of named team. Stephen Browne Lawyers spreads praise across a larger named roster (Tom, Tina, Jessica, Bonnie, Nicole and others), while LHD centers heavily around Frances Lyn with a smaller supporting cast (Kenneth, Casey, Samantha, Abbey, Neha).
- Claim types covered. LHD explicitly lists a wider spread of case types including medical negligence and criminal injury compensation alongside motor vehicle and workers' comp, while Stephen Browne's summary centers on injury, workers comp, and public liability claims.
- Case complexity focus. Stephen Browne Lawyers is called out for persistence on complex, long-running claims through to settlement, whereas LHD is praised more for quick settlements and strong payouts.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: 4.9 (546 reviews)
- LHD Lawyers Perth: 4.9 (356 reviews)
- Services
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: criminal law, commercial business law, family law, law firm
- LHD Lawyers Perth: criminal law, free consultation, commercial business law, law firm
- Best for
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: Complex, drawn-out injury or workers comp disputes needing sustained follow-through
- LHD Lawyers Perth: Claims where you want one consistent point of contact (Frances Lyn) from start to finish
- Case type range
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: Injury, workers comp, public liability
- LHD Lawyers Perth: Motor vehicle accidents, workers comp, medical negligence, criminal injury compensation
- Verification
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: Google-verified
- LHD Lawyers Perth: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Stephen Browne Lawyers: 91
- LHD Lawyers Perth: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Stephen Browne Lawyers
Most clients experience attentive, well-informed case handling. Stephen Browne handles complex injury claims over months or years, with named staff (Tom Prior, Tina Brennan, Jessica Phan, Leticia James, James Lassen, Bonnie Whyte, Nicole Steigen) consistently praised for transparency, follow-up calls and settlement success. One caller reported rude reception; the 546-review average of 4.9 stars suggests this is rare.
Claims handled include motor vehicle accidents, workers compensation, public liability, dog attacks, whiplash, aviation and catastrophic injuries. Many reviewers mention three-year-plus timelines and describe feeling valued despite long waits. The firm operates across Perth Metropolitan and states they cover transport costs for regional clients.
LHD Lawyers Perth
Abbey, Samantha, Frances Lyn, Kenneth Rukunga, Casey, and the broader team deliver personal touch alongside results. Workers' compensation claims dominate the reviews, with clients praising staff who explain processes clearly, check in regularly, and stay calm under stress. Multiple reviewers credit the firm with settlements exceeding their expectations and making long, difficult cases feel manageable. A foreigner noted the team's patience with unfamiliar legal terrain, and those going through injury recovery appreciated the combination of professionalism and genuine care.
Named staff like Meg Olden (Senior Paralegal), Heine Papenfus, and Neha stand out for organisation and attention to detail. Clients mention feeling heard and prioritised from first contact through settlement. The firm positions itself as both thorough and accessible, willing to field questions and walk people through each step without jargon.
Which should you pick?
Pick Stephen Browne Lawyers if
- You want a firm with the largest public review base and a wide bench of named staff to lean on
- Your claim is complicated or long-running and you value persistence through to settlement
- You're dealing with a public liability or workers comp matter and want plain-language guidance throughout
Pick LHD Lawyers Perth if
- You want a single, consistently-praised lead contact in Frances Lyn guiding your claim
- Your matter involves medical negligence or criminal injury compensation, which LHD names explicitly as specialties
- You value speed to settlement and a smaller, closely-knit team over sheer firm size
Verdict
Pick based on the shape of your claim, not the score, since both sit at 92.5-92.6 with matching 4.9 ratings. If your case is complex or could drag on and you want a bigger team with a long history of reviews behind them, Stephen Browne Lawyers fits better. If you want a named lead lawyer steering things personally and your matter might involve medical negligence or criminal injury compensation, LHD Lawyers Perth is the more direct fit.
Need help deciding?
Tell us what you need once and hear from suitable lawyer in Perth Metropolitan.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee for those introductions. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which firm has more reviews?
- Stephen Browne Lawyers has 537 Google reviews compared to LHD Lawyers Perth's 347, though both hold a 4.9 rating.
- Do both firms handle workers' compensation claims?
- Yes. Both are praised specifically for guiding clients through workers' comp disputes with clear communication and strong settlement outcomes.
- Does either firm specialize in medical negligence or criminal injury claims?
- LHD Lawyers Perth explicitly lists medical negligence and criminal injury compensation among its case types, which isn't called out in Stephen Browne Lawyers' summary.
- Is one firm more personal than the other?
- Both earn praise for named staff and personal attention. Stephen Browne Lawyers spreads this across a larger team, while LHD's reviews center heavily on Frances Lyn as the consistent lead contact.