Andrews Legal vs Brand Barristers & Solicitors: which should you pick?
Both firms rate strongly with Perth clients, but they are built for different problems. Andrews Legal is a criminal defence practice, while Brand Barristers & Solicitors works compensation and injury claims. This comparison follows our methodology to weigh up which fits your specific matter rather than just which scores higher.
The differences that matter
- Type of legal matter. Andrews Legal is built for criminal charges and trials, while Brand Barristers & Solicitors focuses on workers compensation, personal injury, medical negligence, and motor vehicle claims.
- Fee structure. Andrews Legal offers fixed-fee arrangements disclosed upfront, whereas Brand Barristers & Solicitors typically charges around 10% of settlement with no upfront costs, which only works for compensation claims.
- Track record specifics. Andrews Legal clients cite charges dismissed, reduced, or discontinued with costs refunded, while Brand Barristers & Solicitors clients cite settlements that beat initial insurance offers.
- Availability. Andrews Legal lists 7-day availability including weekend and evening consultations, which matters if you're facing urgent criminal charges.
- Willingness to take on tough cases. Brand Barristers & Solicitors is specifically praised for accepting difficult claims that other firms decline, a trait not mentioned for Andrews Legal.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Andrews Legal: 4.9 (288 reviews)
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: 5 (308 reviews)
- Services
- Andrews Legal: wills estate planning, criminal law, free consultation, commercial business law
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: commercial business law, law firm, personal injury law, family law
- Best for
- Andrews Legal: Criminal charges, trials, and matters needing urgent representation
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: Workers comp, personal injury, medical negligence, and motor vehicle claims
- Fee model fit
- Andrews Legal: Fixed fee, known cost upfront, suits criminal defence budgeting
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: No-win structure tied to settlement, suits compensation claims with no upfront cash needed
- Named staff mentioned
- Andrews Legal: Tabitha Raphael, Deearnah, Stuart, Mark
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: Emily Dawson, Bella Cooper, Trent Passmore, Ben Hansberry, Kara Lee
- Verification
- Andrews Legal: Google-verified
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Andrews Legal: 92
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Andrews Legal
Mark Andrews and his team (Deearnah, Tabitha, Stuart, Jeremy, and Zarah) earn consistent five-star reviews for criminal work. Clients praise their attention to detail, willingness to explain every step, and honest assessment of risks. Many highlight exceptional outcomes: dismissed cases, reduced sentences, eliminated mandatory minimums. Staff stay responsive through difficult periods, never making false promises.
The firm operates criminal defence across Perth, with pricing starting at $290 for a 45-minute consultation. Reviewers value the personal touch: lawyers take time to understand circumstances, medical history, and rehabilitation efforts before court. Fixed-fee options are available. Across 288 reviews averaging 4.9 stars, nearly all report feeling genuinely heard in otherwise dire situations.
Brand Barristers & Solicitors
People injured at work, in motor accidents, or through medical negligence consistently report feeling supported and well-informed from their first meeting through settlement. The firm handles complex claims with transparent processes and achieves outcomes that beat initial offers, while staff like Emily Dawson, Trent Passmore, Ben Hansberry, and Kara Leigh are frequently named for patience during stressful periods.
Workers compensation, motor vehicle accidents, and personal injury claims dominate the feedback. Clients value that legal steps are explained in plain language, communication stays prompt, and teams investigate thoroughly without hidden costs. The culture appears to centre on treating people as individuals rather than case files, especially when navigating what many describe as the hardest time in their lives.
Which should you pick?
Pick Andrews Legal if
- You're facing criminal charges and need a defence team with a track record of dismissals or reduced charges
- You want a fixed, upfront fee rather than a percentage of any outcome
- You need a lawyer available on evenings or weekends due to urgent proceedings
Pick Brand Barristers & Solicitors if
- You're pursuing a workers compensation, injury, or medical negligence claim
- You'd rather pay nothing upfront and only cover fees from a settlement
- Other firms have already turned down your claim as too difficult
Verdict
The choice here comes down to what kind of legal problem you have, not which firm scores marginally higher. Andrews Legal is the pick for criminal defence, with named lawyers credited for dismantling charges and fixed fees that suit someone facing court costs. Brand Barristers & Solicitors is the pick for compensation and injury claims, where its no-upfront-cost model and reputation for taking on tough cases carry more weight than the small edge in its composite score.
Need help deciding?
Tell us what you need once and hear from suitable lawyer in Perth Metropolitan.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee for those introductions. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which firm is better for a criminal charge?
- Andrews Legal is the clear fit. Reviewers cite charges dismissed, substituted for lesser offences, or discontinued with costs refunded, plus fixed-fee pricing and 7-day availability.
- Which firm is better for a workplace injury or car accident claim?
- Brand Barristers & Solicitors specializes in this area, handling workers compensation, personal injury, medical negligence, and motor vehicle claims with a typical 10% of settlement fee and no upfront cost.
- Do both firms have similar reputations?
- Yes, both carry high composite scores and near-identical positive sentiment (0.81), with Brand Barristers & Solicitors slightly ahead on rating (5.0 vs 4.9) and review volume (302 vs 284).